A Platonic Apology
A lot of thoughts ran through my head when I saw this woman at the café this week. Thoughts about hair, and fur, and footwear, and appropriate pant/sock length, but I am refraining from putting such thoughts down here, because not everyone would take them as intended.
The last time I was on the Orange Line, I took a picture of a fellow passenger and posted it on FaceBook with the caption, “This is why I don’t take the Orange Line.” It was a thirty-degree day in March, but the wind-chill made it feel like zero, and he was wearing shorts. His socks were pulled up as high as they would go, but not high enough to hide the map of veins and tattoos that he had accrued over the course of his lifetime. A fleece pull-over capped the look.
It was the shorts that bothered me – anyone who wears shorts in the midst of winter and is not running to or from the gym will always be considered “off” in my book. Being that this person had a bag of groceries and was leisurely reading a newspaper on the subway indicated that he was not in a dash from the gym to his car or vice-versa. So I posted the photo and soon got called out for judging some innocent fashion victim. The person even went so far as to use one of my favorite F. Scott Fitzgerald quotes against me:
“Whenever you feel like criticizing anyone… just remember that not everyone has had the advantages that you’ve had.”
Ouch. To be honest, “This is why I don’t take the Orange Line” is about the nicest thing I would say about a badly-outfitted stranger, which is why I was taken aback by the call-out. I say much worse things about my boss, to her face, and about my co-workers, than I did about this stranger on the T. But it got me thinking about how I’m perceived. I always sort of assume that people “get” me – that they know my comments and put-downs are never meant in seriousness, nor are they intended to hurt or even judge anyone. They’re part of the “arrogant prick” image I jestfully cultivate. Those who know me, and the close friends I have surrounded myself with, understand this. Otherwise, who would maintain a friendship with me for decades if you’re just going to get shit on every day?
I’ve been called out a few times this year for having made similar comments – and every time it gives me pause and makes me wonder if I am too harsh. Usually I end up apologizing profusely and having Andy bake something for the offended party. The thing is, I only tease the ones I love, and if you don’t know that, or can’t handle that, then you’re not going to be loved by me for much longer. (And if you think I’m harsh on others, you don’t know half of the misery I inflict on myself.)
I feel that anyone who takes offense at those silly jibes doesn’t really know me, and so I’ve learned to keep my distance. I’ll laugh and joke with them on the surface, I’ll interact with them on FaceBook, but I know they’ll never be one of my confidantes, and I’ll never trust them to get close to me. That’s fine – my lifetime circle of friends was forged years ago, and it’s as full and fulfilling as I could ever want. As for my opinion of strangers I see, I reserve the right to judge and condemn on a sartorial basis, because once you go out in public you are subject to public scrutiny.
That said, I will do my best to be a little kinder, because perception is too often confused with reality. I know this, and I can play the game as well as the next guy – but bear in mind that there will be an emptiness behind the friendly smile, and the kinder, gentler version you’ll get will be less-than-genuine. If that’s all you want out of life, have at it. Some people are content to live on the surface, satisfied by a superficial smile of supposed approval. Personally, I would rather die than accept any such happy mediocrity.
“Everyone suspects himself of at least one of the cardinal virtues, and this is mine: I am one of the few honest people that I have ever known.” – F. Scott Fitzgerald